Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

 
 

View User's Journal

Report This Entry Subscribe to this Journal
Memoirs of the Art Discussion Forum
If you've hung around the Art Discussion Forum as long as I have, it's pretty inevitable that you end up repeating yourself. A lot. This stuff is here just in case I need to do so.
Insular Sucks My Balls
Atrum_Silicus

true art skill cannot be taught. it has to be learned with no "teacher" figure. if you really want to learn how to draw, practice. also, if you want to know how to draw correctly...

you will leave this thread immedeately.


Heh, tell that to art colleges.

Have you -seen- paintings of cityscape and buildings before artists started to use a vanishing point? Man didn't figure out that little trick until the early fifteenth century.

On a similar vein early Japanese paintings used isometric perspective in their 2d works because of the fact that they didn't completely allow westerners into their society until the 1800's; that's 300-400 years of not benefiting from three point perspective.

Thinking insularly's the way to go, isn't it? ^~

To say that drawing ability is nothing but raw talent or instinct is a bit boastful; there's lots of things we take for granted thanks to the last couple thousand years of trial and error. It also seems contradictory to claim that art can't truly be learned with a teacher, and then go on to imply something about the "correct" way to draw. Without guidance there -is- no "correct" way; "correct" in itself is only such because a bunch of people agree on what is correct. Can't do that without guidance.

It's up to the individual to decide who they want guidance from. If you don't want it from us I doubt it's any skin off of our backs. We give free advice-- it's not like we're forcing it on the world, just whoever wants to use it.

<center>+ + + Afterthoughts + + +</center>

Yeeah, 'cause, y'know... certainly -I've- never heard of an artist open to outside inspiration, after all. rolleyes


Pink
Community Member
  • [04/05/12 04:55am]
  • [01/31/12 09:01am]
  • [01/31/12 08:58am]
  • [08/08/11 08:59am]
  • [03/14/10 12:49pm]
  • [03/22/09 08:51am]
  • [03/22/09 08:33am]
  • [03/22/09 08:17am]
  • [03/22/09 07:32am]
  • [01/06/08 12:49pm]


  • User Comments: [2]
    I'd have to agree with you on that, but I'd also have to say this. A teacher can teach art, but not originality. I think being original can make you a better artist....or at least, more of a distinguished one. confused

    comment Hanzo10 · Community Member · Thu Feb 16, 2006 @ 04:18am
    User Comments: [2]

     
     
    Manage Your Items
    Other Stuff
    Get GCash
    Offers
    Get Items
    More Items
    Where Everyone Hangs Out
    Other Community Areas
    Virtual Spaces
    Fun Stuff
    Gaia's Games
    Mini-Games
    Play with GCash
    Play with Platinum